I Was On A Sitcom
YouTube · 2026 · 63 min
A sitcom actor's solo show about birthing premature twins.
Overview
Getting recognized in public when you spent nine years playing a sitcom teenager is awkward enough at a grocery store, let alone while getting prepped for an emergency C-section. Eden Sher lets the hospital technician mid-epidural guess where he knows her from until he settles on Modern Family, and she decides not to correct him. That bit sits near the center of I Was On A Sitcom, a solo show whose title acts as a mild decoy for its actual subject: a high-risk twin pregnancy and delivering premature babies at 27 weeks in 2021.
Sher works with minimal props (a whiteboard, a blanket, a stool, and a chair) and leans on broad facial expressions and physical acting to jump between a hospital, a paint shop, and an office filled with 19,350 pieces of paper. Starting The Middle at 17 meant Sue Heck’s life blurred into her own, leaving her hoarding nine years of scripts and trying to figure out who she was once the series wrapped in 2018. When the show turns to her pregnancy, the biology of twins becomes a neat parallel for sharing a brain with a fictional teenager.
Filmed at Dynasty Typewriter in Los Angeles in March 2025 under director Jess Fee, the 63-minute special was released free on YouTube in April 2026. By then the material had been road-tested across American comedy clubs and multiple runs at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, where Sher first debuted the show in 2023 with stage direction by Sara Rejaie and The Middle co-star Charlie McDermott. Around the same time, she was also leaning back into her sitcom past by co-hosting the Middling rewatch podcast with Brock Ciarlelli.
Reviews from the Fringe runs noted that the show sits closer to solo theater than traditional stand-up. The Herald and One4Review both gave the stage show four stars for Sher’s timing and storytelling, while Chortle noted that anyone expecting deep television industry insight may find the sitcom premise under-delivered, and that her heavy acting-out sometimes leans toward a drama school showcase.
Watch the full special
Notable bits & set list
-
Public encounters with fans who believe she is Sue Heck
Recounts destabilizing real-life encounters where fans assume she wears braces in real life, compare her to their daughters, and request videos for family members like Barb.
-
The biological mechanics of twin conception as an identity metaphor
Explains how identical twins split inside the body, using it as an analogy for her own identity splitting in two between herself and her sitcom character.
-
Cleaning out an office filled with 215 episodes of scripts to make a nursery
Details attempting to build a perfect minimalist nursery out of an office packed with 19,350 sheets of hoarded scripts from nine years of filming The Middle.
-
Surprise twin pregnancy and traumatic delivery
Enacts the harrowing medical procedures and terror of birthing premature twins, including being recognized by medical personnel while on the delivery table.
Details
- Released
- Taped
- Los Angeles, United States
- Runtime
- 63 min
- Where
- YouTube (free)
- Director
- Jess Fee, Charlie McDermott, Sara Rejaie
- Charts & notes
- Playbill Playhouse Pick of the Fringe
Manic sitcom perkiness turned inside out for raw hospital panic.
Get an email when there's a new special. Use your email or Google.
Similar specials
-
Johnny Ater What The Frig?
YouTube
-
Kasper Nelson Black Kasper: Da Bootleg Project Live!
Comedy Dynamics
-
Lavell Crawford New Look, Same Funny
Comedy Dynamics
-
Martin Lawrence Martin Lawrence Live: Runteldat
Paramount Pictures