It's Bad for Ya
HBO · 2008 · 69 min
A final hour targeting the self-esteem movement and civil liberties.
George Carlin refuses to soften his worldview for a quiet exit. Taped less than four months before his death, the hour opens with the comic detailing the distinct advantages of being a seventy-year-old man. He outlines how leaning into the persona of an “old fuck” lets him manipulate social expectations and avoid tedious conversations, setting an abrasive baseline for the rest of the evening.
Filmed live at the Wells Fargo Center for the Arts in Santa Rosa, California, in March 2008, the special features a cozy living room backdrop that directly contrasts the material. Carlin systematically goes after the self-esteem movement, modern parenting tropes, and the concept of natural rights. The closing piece asserts that civil liberties do not exist, arguing instead that Americans operate under a system of temporary privileges granted by the state. The release later earned a posthumous Grammy for Best Comedy Album.
The set list
-
Being an 'Old Fuck' and deleting friends from address books
Carlin addresses his age bluntly, rejects euphemisms like 'old man' in favor of 'old fuck', and breaks down the unsentimental etiquette of crossing deceased acquaintances out of his address book.
-
Empty platitudes spoken when people die
Mocks standard societal condolences like 'I'm keeping him in my thoughts', questioning where exactly those thoughts fit between bodily discomfort and vulgar impulses.
-
Today's professional parents and 'child worship'
Attacks modern helicopter parenting, participation trophies where no child ever loses, play dates, and banning dodgeball or tag, longing for days when kids just sat in a yard digging a hole with a stick.
-
Ethnic and national pride
Argues that pride should be reserved for personal achievements rather than accidental circumstances of birth like nationality, ethnicity, or genetics.
-
The closer (spoiler). Show it
You Have No Rights
Concludes that either people have unlimited rights or no rights at all, suggesting that if someone claims a right to an opinion you dislike, you have the right to shoot them and walk away.
How it plays
- Tone
- Dark, satirical, cynical, combative, and unsentimental.
- On stage
- Cantankerous, razor-sharp iconoclast and self-described 'old fuck' channeling righteous indignation with passionate, fiery evangelism.
- Pace
- Physically more stooped and deliberate in movement due to age, but delivered with strong, guttural vocals, rapid-fire verbal dexterity, and fierce conviction.
- About
- Aging and mortality, Modern parenting and child worship, Empty platitudes and clichés, Religion and swearing on the Bible, Ethnic and national pride, Human rights and government bullshit
What the critics said
Universally praised as a fitting, fiery swansong demonstrating that Carlin's intellect, linguistic skill, and righteous fury remained undiminished at the end of his life.
In the room: Raucous laughter and enthusiastic applause in response to his brutal honesty and sharp-edged observations.
Backstory
Televised live on HBO on March 1, 2008, less than four months before Carlin's death on June 22, 2008. The stage was designed around a cozy living room theme, and the material reflected Carlin confronting his own aging and impending mortality.
Details
- Released
- Taped
- Wells Fargo Center for the Arts, Santa Rosa
- Runtime
- 69 min
- Where
- HBO
- Director
- Rocco Urbisci
- Honors
- Grammy Award for Best Comedy Album (51st Grammy Awards)Nominee: Outstanding Variety, Music Or Comedy Special (60th Primetime Emmy Awards)
- Topics
- Before
- Life Is Worth Losing (2005)
More from George Carlin
-
Napalm and Silly Putty
HighBridge Audio · Album
-
Back in Town
HBO
If you liked this
-
Lewis Black Stark Raving Black
Comedy Central
-
Chris Rock Selective Outrage
Netflix
-
Auggie Smith Cult Following
Stand Up! Records · Album
-
Ronny Chieng Love To Hate It
Netflix
