Skip to content
Brick Wall Comedy
Brick Wall Comedy

The Day the Laughter Died

Andrew Dice Clay

Def American Records · Album · 1990 · 1 h 42 min

A deliberate anti-comedy experiment recorded in front of unsuspecting holiday tourists.

Listen free on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Fresh off becoming the first comedian to sell out Madison Square Garden, Andrew Dice Clay made a pivot that remains one of the strangest moves in comedy history. Produced by Rick Rubin, The Day the Laughter Died is an anti-comedy endurance test. Clay drops into Dangerfield’s in New York unannounced to perform for unsuspecting holiday tourists. Instead of his signature arena-ready nursery rhymes, he delivers flat setups, stalls for time, and actively antagonizes the 200-person crowd. He leans into the hostile silence. When people inevitably walk out, their exit becomes the focus of the act.

Recorded over two nights in December 1989 and released as a double album, the tape operates as a deconstruction of his own macho persona. He subjects the audience to bizarre, repetitive bits like the rambling track “Hour Back…Get It?” while entirely abandoning the rhythm of a standard club set. The release baffled critics and alienated casual fans, but the hostility and refusal to pander earned the project a cult following among comics. Instead of cashing in on his stadium status, he used his fame to hold a room hostage.

The set list

4 bits

  1. Attacking a guy from Texas wearing an ugly sweater.

    Relentlessly mocking the man on the spot for dutifully wearing an ugly sweater bought for him by his girlfriend.

  2. The naming convention behind multiple sclerosis.

    Ruminating in an absurd, literalist manner on why the disease is called 'multiple' sclerosis rather than just getting it once.

  3. Interrogating a family from out of town wearing matching winter coats and hats.

    Directing profane and sexually explicit remarks toward the daughters and growing increasingly infuriated that the father was laughing along instead of defending them.

  4. Opening track featuring 55 seconds of silence and heavy breathing.

    Intentionally refusing to start the set with jokes, letting the room sit in awkward silence with only audible breathing and microphone noise.

How it plays

Tone
Hostile, whiny, irritated, vulgar, and deliberately alienating.
On stage
Adversarial, flat, raw, and unapologetically confrontational, stripping away rehearsed arena bravado to deliberately agitate the room.
Pace
Unstructured and unhurried, featuring prolonged uncomfortable silences, audible breathing, cigarette smoking, and shifts between quiet indifference and wrathful sputtering.
About
sex, relationships between men and women, masculinity, popular culture, holiday season

What the critics said

Contemporary music critics criticized the album as overlong, tedious, and filled with unedited filler that failed to justify a double-disc release; however, comedians and later critics reassessed it as a daring, fearless anti-comedy masterpiece.

In the room: Uncomfortable, quiet, and hostile; patrons sat in bewildered silence, heckled him, and walked out mid-performance.

Summed up from reviews, articles and listings. Sources: en.wikipedia.org, allmusic.com, discogs.com, wikidata.org, vulture.com, vice.com, latimes.com.

Backstory

Producer Rick Rubin conceived recording an unadvertised set in a small, 250-capacity club during the post-Christmas holiday season in front of an unsuspecting crowd that was largely unfamiliar with or unprepared for his act, intentionally aiming for a late-night set devoid of conventional setup-punchline jokes.

Details

Released
Taped
1989, Dangerfield's, New York City
Runtime
1 h 42 min
Where
Def American Records (album)
Topics
After
Dice Rules (1991)

More from Andrew Dice Clay

If you liked this