Skip to content
Brick Wall Comedy
Brick Wall Comedy
Promotional art for Nanette
Cover image credit: via TMDB

Nanette

Hannah Gadsby

Netflix · 2018 · 69 min

An Australian comic deconstructs the limits of the punchline.

Hannah Gadsby begins with traditional self-deprecating stand-up about growing up closeted in Tasmania, only to systematically dismantle the mechanics of the medium. The performance operates as a public resignation from comedy, with Gadsby arguing that the tension-and-release structure of jokes forces marginalized performers to freeze their trauma into palatable punchlines. By pulling back the curtain on the real, violent endings of anecdotes previously played for laughs, the set transitions from light observation into an indictment of societal complacency.\n\nFilmed at the Sydney Opera House and released by Netflix in June 2018, the special took Gadsby from a respected Australian veteran to a global household name. Notable segments include a sharp-tongued art history lecture targeting the misogyny of Pablo Picasso and the romanticizing of Vincent van Gogh’s mental illness. Gadsby contrasts these historical figures against personal stories of homophobia and the exhaustion of self-deprecation.\n\nThe show polarized the comedy community, sparking intense debates about what constitutes stand-up. While many praised its formal audacity, some critics argued that its rejection of humor in the second half moved it closer to a theatrical monologue than a comedy set.

The set list

5 bits

  1. The pub encounter and subverted callback

    Initially recounts being threatened by a man outside a pub for flirting with his girlfriend as a lighthearted misunderstanding, then calls back to the story to reveal the man returned, used a homophobic slur, and brutally beat her, demonstrating how standard punchlines truncate trauma.

  2. Pablo Picasso and Cubism

    Critiques Picasso's affair with teenage Marie-Thérèse Walter, rejecting the normalization of male abuse under the guise of artistic genius and pointing out that none of Cubism's perspectives belonged to women.

  3. Vincent van Gogh and romanticizing mental illness

    Rebuts the cultural tendency to romanticize mental illness as the catalyst for artistic creativity, asserting that artists do not invent zeitgeists but respond to them.

  4. Quiet gays vs. Pride celebrations

    Jokes about not fitting into the loud extravagance of Mardi Gras or Pride parades, wondering where the quiet gays are supposed to go.

  5. Quitting comedy due to self-deprecation

    Argues that for someone who exists on the margins, self-deprecating humor is not humility but humiliation, announcing she must quit comedy because the form demands the suppression of full stories.

How it plays

Tone
Raw, deeply personal, razor-sharp, devastating, angry, and defiant.
On stage
Begins in an unassuming, gentle, nebbishy, and self-deprecating manner holding the mic with two fists, then deliberately sheds that persona to become deeply serious, impassioned, assertive, and defiant.
Pace
Shifts from traditional, witty stand-up rhythm to prolonged, tension-heavy silences and emotionally eviscerating oratory without diffusing audience unease with punchlines.
About
Deconstruction of stand-up comedy conventions, Self-deprecating humor as humiliation for marginalized people, Homophobia and growing up queer in Tasmania, Trauma, sexual violence, and male impunity, Misogyny and the excuse of artistic genius (Picasso, Van Gogh), Gender nonconformity and public identity

What the critics said

Hannah Gadsby: Nanette brilliantly moves modern comedy into nakedly honest new territory, pivoting from dry humor to raw, powerful storytelling.

In the room: Rapt, stunned, emotionally challenged, and held in prolonged collective tension.

Summed up from reviews, articles and listings. Sources: en.wikipedia.org, allmovie.com, netflix.com, ew.com, chortle.co.uk, newyorker.com, decider.com, vulture.com, variety.com, theguardian.com.

Backstory

Conceived partly in response to the Australian plebiscite on same-sex marriage, following diagnoses of autism and ADHD, rooted in her experience growing up in Tasmania where homosexuality was criminalized until 1997, and intersecting with the broader cultural fury of the #MeToo movement.

Details

Released
Taped
Sydney Opera House
Runtime
69 min
Where
Netflix
Director
Madeleine Parry, John Olb
Honors
Peabody Award (2018)Primetime Emmy Award - Outstanding Writing for a Variety Special (2019)Primetime Emmy Award Nomination - Outstanding Variety Special (Pre-Recorded) (2019) and 6 more
Topics
After
Douglas (2020)

More from Hannah Gadsby

If you liked this