Full special — watch free here
Choosing The Wrong Story To Tell
YouTube · 2025 · 52 min
Unrushed Australian storytelling about the failure of everyday social scripts.
Overview
Most everyday human interactions rely on an unspoken script: the automated exchange of ‘Hey mate,’ ‘Good thanks,’ and the polite refusal of a paper receipt. Lewis Garnham builds his hour around what happens when that conversational autopilot malfunctions. He is laconic and patient on stage, letting long narratives breathe without rushing to bail them out with quick misdirection.
Filmed in October 2024 at Max Watt’s in Melbourne and released in 2025, this marked Garnham’s second special following his debut, Lewis Garnham Hit A Pigeon With His Bike. The live show won a Moosehead Award at the 2024 Melbourne International Comedy Festival and earned four stars from The Scotsman at Edinburgh Fringe before being acquired by 800 Pound Gorilla Media.
The centerpiece is an extended encounter with a man experiencing memory loss, followed by a late-night Uber Eats delivery that slowly unravels over small, misread signals.
Notable bits & set list
-
Absent-mindedly shouting 'fuck yeah!' at a student while working as a teacher's aide.
Humorously dissects the inappropriate slip in authority and the resulting mortification in front of students.
-
A chance encounter with a person suffering from amnesia.
A charming, Wes Anderson-esque story that delivers a surprising kicker for the comic.
-
An Uber Eats delivery order.
A heartwarming personal anecdote exploring moments of genuine connection.
-
Picking up a hitchhiker with his girlfriend.
An embarrassing situation proving that no good deed goes unpunished.
-
Development of genetically modified tearless onions.
Used as an analogy for humanity's extreme efforts to eliminate minor pains and discomforts at the cost of authentic experience.
-
Demands of working at Coles and interactions with a recurring colleague.
Anecdotes used as personal teaching moments and thematic callbacks throughout the hour.
-
The cultural and historical significance of the screaming goat meme.
An absurd philosophical dive into internet humor and collective obsessions.
Details
- Released
- Taped
- 2024, Max Watt's, Melbourne
- Runtime
- 52 min
- Where
- YouTube (free)
- Director
- Harry Quinlan
- Charts & notes
- Moosehead Award recipient (2024)
Slow-rolling pub yarns that turn awkward social missteps into existential dilemmas.
Get an email when there's a new special. Use your email or Google.
Similar specials
-
Arnór Daði Big, Small Town Kid
Stand Up! Records
-
Sean Sullivan Song & Dance Man
Comedy Dynamics · Album
-
Geoff Tate Hindsight, Vol. 1: July 5, 2013
Blonde Medicine · Album
-
Adele Givens Comedy Central Presents
Comedy Central
-
Dave Stone Hogwash
Comedy Dynamics · Album
-
Ryan Conner Live From D.C.
Comedy Dynamics