Skip to content
Brick Wall Comedy
Brick Wall Comedy
Promotional art for Our Man in Chicago
Cover image credit:

Source

Our Man in Chicago

Jeff Garlin

Netflix · 2019 · 58 min

Loose, conversational stand-up with minimal preparation and heavy crowd work.

Watch on Netflix(opens in a new tab)

Jeff Garlin does not write down jokes so much as he searches for them in real time, pacing the stage with a loose energy that feels more like an off-the-cuff conversation than a televised comedy set. He is less concerned with setups and punchlines than with finding a groove with the audience, turning a simple crowd interaction into a sprawling, multi-minute narrative.

Recorded at the Park West theater in his hometown of Chicago, Illinois, this 2019 Netflix release marked the thirty-seventh anniversary of Garlin’s stand-up debut. At this point in his career, he was widely known for co-starring as the exasperated manager Jeff Greene on Curb Your Enthusiasm and playing the short-tempered patriarch on ABC’s The Goldbergs. That established television profile makes his unstructured, heavily improvisational stage presence a surprise for viewers expecting a tightly rehearsed, traditional hour of comedy.

Garlin works with minimal preparation, using a handful of general themes like love, loss, and food addiction as loose guides. Notable moments include a story about his minor role in RoboCop 3, where his insistence on eating a real doughnut during his scene resulted in him consuming 36 of them and getting incredibly sick, and a prolonged interrogation of a young couple in the front row that results in a highly specific hypothetical about unrequited love in Milwaukee. He also targets an audience member wearing boat shoes on dry land.

The loose nature of the show was partly born of a last-minute panic. Garlin had originally prepared a structured, theme-based set, but after seeing Paul Rudd perform a wedding-toast-style monologue on Saturday Night Live just two weeks prior to the taping, he abandoned his plans to avoid any similarity. While some critics and audiences found the resulting hour a bit aimless and lacking in traditional punchlines, fans of Garlin’s chaotic, warm style appreciated the unfiltered look into his comedic process.

The set list

5 bits

  1. Constant questions about Larry David

    Jokes about his immense success being overshadowed by fans who invariably only ask him what Larry David is really like.

  2. The Goldbergs HR investigation

    Recounts sitting on set in his underwear in a Barcalounger repeatedly making crude jokes about his aching vagina until reported to Sony Human Resources.

  3. Reverence for donuts and sugar sobriety

    Discusses his decades-long food addiction, reverently describing donuts like a first kiss and declaring ice cream proof of God.

  4. Jamie and Lydia front-row crowdwork

    Engages an audience member attending with a female college friend, sympathetically diagnosing him with the agony of unrequited love.

  5. The closer (spoiler). Show it

    Recommending John Mulaney to the audience closer

    Delivers a direct-to-camera plea instructing viewers to stop watching his special and watch John Mulaney's comedy instead.

How it plays

Tone
Conversational, intimate, quirky, offbeat, and honest.
On stage
Exuberant, candid, vulnerable, and self-deprecating; performed wearing a suit and beard.
Pace
Rambling, conversational, and loose with low punchline density; relies on on-the-spot tangents and improvisation over tightly scripted setups.
About
food addiction and sugar recovery, love and loss, stand-up career milestones and bad gigs, success and co-stars, on-set HR reprimand on The Goldbergs, unrequited love

What the critics said

Reviews described the special as loose, rambling, and reminiscent of a pleasant podcast or documentary rather than a structured joke set, praising its candor and warmth while noting its low joke density.

In the room: Intimate and spontaneous room dynamic at Park West where crew and cameras remained visible and crowd interactions steered the set.

Summed up from reviews, articles and listings. Sources: themoviedb.org, letterboxd.com, latestnetflix.com, decider.com, vulture.com, thecomicscomic.com, gq.com, chicagohumanities.org, forbes.com.

Backstory

Filmed in his hometown of Chicago on the 37th anniversary of his comedy debut; explores his Second City improv background, personal history with food addiction and sugar sobriety, and an HR controversy on the set of The Goldbergs.

Details

Released
Taped
Park West, Chicago
Runtime
58 min
Where
Netflix
Director
Christopher Storer
Topics
Before
HBO Comedy Half-Hour (1998)

More from Jeff Garlin

If you liked this